The Moon Upstairs was originally a Mott The Hoople song co-written by Ian and Mick Ralphs from Brain Capers. It is a full-tilt rocker that was a profane and defiant song against Island, their label at the time since things were not going well at all. Mott was loud, aggressive, and desperate so the writing was similar. For example, they write:
We ain't bleeding you we're feeding you but you're too f*cking slow
Ian likens the chaos of original recording as anticipating the Sex Pistols. The song is built upon the manic energy of Guy Stevens. He would wind the band up so tight it was an elastic band or a dog unleashed and they would just explode. That was the intensity that Stevens was striving for. Hunter imagined the bailiffs at the door ready to take the band out. It was recorded at John Dee, Oslo Norway 8th October 2012.
Ian Hunter On Track for Sonicbond Publishing, TheDoctorOfDigital@pm.me
The live version was not released until Bag of Tricks Vol. 3 on the box set only from a gig in 2012.
The Moon Upstairs is another full-tilt rocker with is in part a message of defiance to Island: "We ain't bleeding you, we're feeding you, but you're to f***ing slow".There is a live version from 2012.
(Ian Hunter/Mick Ralphs)
Well my brother he was a drinking man
And I asked him for release
He said this won't do you no good
And sent for the police
Well they busted me for nothing
'Cos they said I was insane
So they let my body go
But they locked away my brain
Well I wandered freely as a bird that had broken both its wings
And I hated them and they hated me and I hated everthing
And I realise that to survive well my body is not mine
And I feel neglected feel rejected
Living in the wrong time
And to those of you who always laugh
Let this be your epitaph
And my head is down and I'm called a clown by comedians that grace
The living stage of every page of worthless meaningless space
But I swear to you before we're through you're gonna feel our every blow
We ain't bleeding you we're feeding you but you're too f*cking slow
And to those of you who always laugh
Let this be your epitaph
Ian Hunter Box Set: "Stranded In Reality"
Sleeve and track listing
Proper SHADES1
Ian Hunter
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
- Who Do You Love
- Lounge Lizard
- Boy
- 3,000 Miles From Here
- The Truth, The Whole Truth, Nuthin' But The Truth
- It Ain't Easy When You Fall/Shades Off
- I Get So Excited
- Colwater High
- One Fine Day
- Once Bitten Twice Shy (single edit)
- Who Do You Love (single edit)
- Shades Off (poem)
- Boy (edit)
All American Alien Boy
- Letter To Britannia From The Union Jack
- All American Alien Boy
- Irene Wilde
- Restless Youth
- Rape
- You Nearly Did Me In
- Apathy 83
- God (Take 1)
- To Rule Britannia From Union Jack (session outtake)
- All American Alien Boy (early single version)
- Irene Wilde (Number One) (session outtake)
- Weary Anger (session outtake)
- Apathy (session outtake)
- (God) Advice To A Friend (session outtake)
Overnight Angels
- Golden Opportunity (4:31)
- Shallow Crystals (3:58)
- Overnight Angels (5:12)
- Broadway (3:46)
- Justice of the Peace (3:01)
- (Miss) Silver Dime (4:34)
- Wild n' Free (3:08)
- The Ballad of Little Star (2:32)
- To Love a Woman (3:54)
- England Rocks(2:53)
You're Never Alone With A Schizophrenic
- Just Another Night
- Wild East
- Cleveland Rocks
- Ships
- When the Daylight Comes
- Life After Death
- Standin' In My Light
- Bastard
- The Outsider
- Don't Let Go (demo)
- Ships (take 1)
- When The Daylight Comes (early version)
- The Other Side of Life (Just Another Night early version)
- Whole Lotta Shakin' Goin' On
Welcome To The Club
Disc 1
- FBI
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
- Angeline
- Laugh at Me
- All the Way From Memphis
- I Wish I Was Your Mother
- Irene Wilde
- Just Another Night
- Cleveland Rocks
- Standin' In My Light
- Bastard
Disc 2
- Walkin' With a Mountain/Rock 'n' Roll Queen
- All the Young Dudes
- Slaughter On Tenth Avenue
- One of the Boys
- The Golden Age of Rock 'n' Roll
- When the Daylight Comes
- Once Bitten Twice Shy/Bastard/Cleveland Rocks (medley)
- We Gotta Get Out of Here
- Silver Needles
- Man O' War
- Sons and Daughters
Short Back And Sides
- Central Park n' West
- Lisa Likes Rock n' Roll
- I Need Your Love
- Old Records Never Die
- Noises
- Rain
- Gun Control
- Theatre of the Absurd
- Leave Me Alone
- Keep on Burning
- I Need Your Love (rough mix)
- Old Records Never Die (version 1)
- Rain (alternate mix)
- Theatre of the Absurd (alternate version)
All Of The Good Ones Are Taken
- All of the Good Ones Are Taken
- Every Step of the Way
- Fun
- Speechless
- Death 'n' Glory Boys
- That Girl Is Rock 'n' Roll
- Somethin's Goin' On
- Captain Void 'n' the Video Jets
- Seeing Double
- All of the Good Ones Are Taken
- Traitor (12" single b-side)
- Somethin's Goin' On (single radio edit)
YUI Orta
- American Music
- The Loner
- Women's Intuition
- Tell It Like It Is
- Livin' In a Heart
- Big Time
- Cool
- Beg a Little Love
- Following In Your Footsteps
- Sons 'n' Lovers
- Pain
- How Much More Can I Take
- Sweet Dreamer
Ian Hunter's Dirty Laundry
- Dancing on the Moon
- Another Fine Mess
- Scars
- Never Trust a Blonde
- Psycho Girl
- My Revolution
- Good Girls
- Red Letter Day
- Invisible Strings
- Everyone's a Fool
- Junkee Love
- The Other Man
BBC Live In Concert
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
- How Much More Can I Take
- Beg a Little Love
- Following In Your Footsteps
- Just Another Night
- Sweet Dreamer
- (Give Me Back My) Wings
- Standin' In My Light
- Bastard
- The Loner
- You're Never Too Old To Hit The Big Time
- All The Way From Memphis
- Irene Wilde
The Artful Dodger
- Too Much
- Now Is The Time
- Something To Believe In
- Resurrection Mary
- Walk On Water
- 23A, Swan Hill
- Michael Picasso
- Open My Eyes
- The Artful Dodger
- Skeletons (In Your Closet)
- Still The Same
- Fuck It Up (1996 single track)
Rant
- Ripoff
- Good Samaritan
- Death of a Nation
- Purgatory
- American Spy
- Dead Man Walkin' (Eastenders)
- Wash Us Away
- Morons
- Soap And Water
- Knees Of My Heart
- No One
- Still Love Rock 'n' Roll
Strings Attached
Disc 1
- Rest In Peace
- All Of The Good Ones Are Taken
- I Wish I Was Your Mother
- Twisted Steel
- Boy
- 23A Swan Hill
- Waterlow
- All The Young Dudes
- Irene Wilde
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
Disc 2
- Rollerball
- Ships
- A Nightingale Sang In Berkeley Square
- Michael Picasso
- Wash Us Away
- Don't Let Go
- All The Way From Memphis
- Roll Away The Stone
- Saturday Gigs
- Dead Man Walkin' (Eastenders) (bonus track)
- Your Way (bonus track)
Shrunken Heads
- Words (Big Mouth)
- Fuss About Nothin'
- When The World Was Round
- Brainwashed
- Shrunken Heads
- Soul Of America
- How's Your House
- Guiding Light
- Stretch
- I Am What I Hated When I Was Young
- Read 'em 'n' Weep
- Your Eyes (bonus EP track)
- Wasted (bonus EP track)
- Real Or Imaginary (bonus EP track)
- When The World Was Round (single radio edit)
Man Overboard
- The Great Escape
- Arms And Legs
- Up And Running
- Man Overboard
- Babylon Blues
- Girl From The Office
- Flowers
- These Feelings
- Win It All
- Way With Words
- River Of Tears
When I'm President
- Comfortable (Flyin' Scotsman)
- Fatally Flawed
- When I'm President
- What For
- Black Tears
- Saint
- Just The Way You Look Tonight
- Wild Bunch
- Ta Shunka Witco (Crazy Horse)
- I Don't Know What You Want
- Life
- When I'm President (radio edit single)
Live In The UK 2010
- Sea Diver
- Arms And Legs
- Words (Big Mouth)
- The Great Escape
- Ships
- Irene Wilde
- Flowers
- Soul Of America
- Man Overboard
- Waterlow
- Michael Picasso
- Wash Us Away
- 23A Swan Hill
- Sweet Jane
- All The Young Dudes
Tilting The Mirror - Rarities
Disc 1
- All-American Alien Boy (Single A-side)
- You Nearly Did Me In (Single A-side)
- Common Disease (Alien Boy Outtake)
- If the Slipper Don't Fit (Alien Boy Outtake)
- The Outsider (Early Version)
- Alibi (Schizophrenic Jam)
- When the Daylight Comes (Single A-side)
- Just Another Night (Electric version #3)
- Detroit (Rough Mix Instrumental)
- Na Na Na
- I Believe in You
- Listen to the Eight Track
- You Stepped Into My Dreams
- Venus in the Bathtub
- China (Ronson Vocal)
- Detroit (Outtake 5 - Vocal)
- Na Na Na (Extended Mix)
Disc 2
- Bluebirds (Demo)
- All is Forgiven (Demo)
- Sunshine Eyes (Demo)
- (I'm the) Teacher
- Great Expectations (You Never Know What To Expect)
- Good Man in a Bad Time
- Wake Up Call
- Ill Wind (Demo)
- Women's Intuition (Single Edit)
- Ain't No Way to Treat a Lady (Artful Dodger Outtake)
- Resurrection Mary (Trio Version)
- Something To Believe In (Trio Version)
- Waterlow (Trio Version)
- I'm In Awe (Rant Outtake)
- Avalanche (Rant Outtake)
- Morons (Early Version)
- One More Time
If You Wait Long Enough For Anything, You Can Get It On Sale
Disc 1
- FBI1
- Once Bitten Twice Shy1
- One Of The Boys1
- Laugh At Me1
- I Wish I Was Your Mother1
- Sons and Daughters1
- Irene Wilde1
- Just Another Night1
- Life After Death1
- Sweet Angeline1
- Standin' in My Light1
- Bastard1
- The Golden Age of Rock 'n' Roll1
- All The Way From Memphis1
Disc 2
- All The Young Dudes1
- Walkin' With A Mountain/Rock 'n' Roll Queen1
- Cleveland Rocks1
- When The Daylight Comes1
- Letter to Britannia From The Union Jack2
- Ships3
- Gun Control4
- Violence4
- Is Your Love In Vain4
- Lisa Likes Rock n' Roll4
- Theatre Of The Absurd4
- Walkin' With A Mountain4
Bag Of Tricks - Live Rarities Vol 1
- A Sane Revolution
- Wild East1
- (I'm The) Teacher1
- While You Were Looking at Me1
- Day Tripper2
- Pain3
- Resurrection Mary4
- Michael Picasso4
- Shades Off/Boy5
- Ill Wind5
- Good Samaritan6
- Purgatory6
- American Spy6
- Death of a Nation6
Bag Of Tricks - Live Rarities Vol 2
- Rock And Roll Queen/Death May Be Your Santa Claus1
- One Of The Boys1
- The Original Mixed-Up Kid1
- Knockin' On Heaven's Door1
- Twisted Steel1
- 23a Swan Hill1
- Dead Man Walkin' (EastEnders)1
- Knees of My Heart2
- The Truth, The Whole Truth And Nothing But the Truth2
- Rollerball2
- Irene Wilde2
- Roll Away The Stone2
- Lounge Lizard3
- The Outsider4
Bag Of Tricks - Live Rarities Vol 3
- Hymn For The Dudes1
- All-American Alien Boy1
- Morons/Marionette/Broadway1
- Following In Your Footsteps2
- Dancing On the Moon3
- Shallow Crystals3
- The Ballad of Little Star3
- Just The Way You Look Tonight4
- Black Tears4
- Isolation4
- Alice4
- The Moon Upstairs4
- (Ta Shunka Witco) Crazy Horse4
- When I'm President5
- Now Is The Time6
- Shades Off
Acoustic Shadows - Live
- Where Do You All Come From
- Wash Us Away
- The Other Man
- Scars
- Soul of America/I Wish I Was Your Mother
- Shrunken Heads
- Rain
- Sons 'n' Lovers
- Sweet Jane
- Irene Wilde/Ships/Letter to Britannia from the Union Jack
- Honaloochie Boogie/How's Your House
- Twisted Steel
- When the World Was Round
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
Recorded at The Mick Jagger Theatre, Dartford, Kent 2nd March 2008
Experiments - Previously Unreleased Recordings
- You're Messin' With The King Of Rock 'n' Roll
- Money Can't Buy Love
- More To Love
- Look Before You Leap
- My Love (The Jar)
- Demolition Derby
- Just Want It Real
- Coincidence
- Big Black Cadillac
- San Diego Freeway
- Nobody's Perfect
- Too Much (All I Ever Wanted) (early version)
- Artful Dodger (early version)
- Michael Picasso (early version)
- A Little Rock 'n' Roll (Artful Dodger outtake)
- Testosterone (Artful Dodger outtake)
- The Man In Me (Ian Hunter and Tribes)
- Salvation
It Never Happened - DVD
DVD 1
- Once Bitten Twice Shy (CBS promo video 1975)
- All-American Alien Boy (Studio film 1975)
- Standin' in My Light (Fragment) (Top Pop TV - Holland 1979
- Irene Wilde (Chrysalis promo film 1980)
- Once Bitten Twice Shy (Chrysalis promo film 1980)
- We Gotta Get Out Of Here (Chrysalis promo film 1980)
- Laugh at Me (Rockpalast 1980)
- Irene Wilde (Rockpalast 1980)
- I Wish I Was Your Mother (Rockpalast 1980)
- All of The Good Ones Are Taken (CBS promo video 1983)
- While You Were Looking At Me (Toronto 1988)
- Day Tripper (Toronto 1988)
- Beg a Little Love (The Dominion, London 1989)
- Following in Your Footsteps (The Dominion, London 1989)
- (Give Me Back My) Wings (The Dominion, London 1989)
- The Loner (The Dominion, London 1989)
- American Music (PolyGram promo video 1990)
- My Revolution (Scandinavian NRK TV Session 1995)
- Michael Picasso (MTV Take It To The Bridge Session 1997)
- Irene Wilde (MTV Take It To The Bridge Session 1997)
- When the World Was Round (Jerkin' Crocus Promo Video 2007)
- Flowers (BBC Jools Holland Show 2009)
- Once Bitten Twice Shy (BBC Jools Holland Show 2009)
- When I'm President (Proper Promo Film 2012)
DVD 2
Ryerson Theatre Toronto, Canada 1979
- Trailer and Interview
- Life After Death
- Just Another Night
- The Golden Age of Rock 'n' Roll
- Standin' in My Light
- Bastard
- Cleveland Rocks
- All The Young Dudes
- When The Daylight Comes
- Slaughter On 10th Avenue
Ian Hunter Rocks (Dr. Pepper Festival, New York 1981)
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
- Gun Control
- Central Park n' West
- All The Way From Memphis
- I Need Your Love
- Noises
- Just Another Night
- Cleveland Rocks
- Irene Wilde
- All the Young Dudes
Strings Attached (The Sentrum, Oslo, Norway 2002)
- Rest in Peace
- All of The Good Ones Are Taken
- I Wish I Was Your Mother
- Twisted Steel
- Don't Let Go
- Boy
- Wash Us Away
- 23a Swan Hill
- Waterlow
- All the Young Dudes
- Irene Wilde
- Once Bitten Twice Shy
- Rollerball
- Ships
- A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square
- All the Way from Memphis
- Saturday Gigs
- Michael Picasso
- Roll Away the Stone
Review
It was 2013 when fans were first teased with "coming soon... the ultimate Ian Hunter box set". Well, over three years in the making and what was originally going to be a 24-disc set is now a 30-disc whopper. And yes, it has been worth the wait.
OK, so what's in the box? Well there's every (regular) album that Ian has ever released, with the exception of 2016's Fingers Crossed and 2004's live double The Truth...Every album has been remastered, in some cases with bonus tracks (eg single edits) that haven't appeared on previous issues. Each is presented in a mini-LP replica sleeve, complete with an inner sleeve (for the CD itself) and a booklet. Sound quality is excellent throughout.
In addition, there are a further nine discs of rare and previously-unreleased material. There is an acoustic gig (Acoustic Shadows) from 2008, which is an interesting contrast to the (also acoustic) Live In The UK 2010 disc (also included here). Two discs of rarities (Tilting The Mirror) gather together bonus tracks that have appeared on "bonus CDs" on previous releases. Bag Of Tricks gather together various live tracks recorded over the years, including the 2002 Manchester gig that was previously thought to be "lost". It neatly showcases the last 30 years of live shows, from Toronto in 1987 through to Sheffield in 2013 and Tokyo in 2015. Fascinating.
Then there's If You Wait Long Enough... which included for the first time the 1979 Hammersmith Odeon gig. OK, an hour of this show was broadcast on BBC Radio One but this is the full show (nearly two hours!) and an improvement on the original BBC mix. We also get a 1981 show recorded in San Fransisco. This is interesting because it features Robbie Alter on guitar and Mick Ronson - on keyboards!
Experiments is fascinating. These are demos and (complete) unreleased tracks from the past thirty or so years. Look Before You Leap is a great power ballad (is that Ronno on guitar?), while Salvation (written in 1997 but not recorded until 2008) is a great way to close the collection. Ian has said it would be on his last record, and Proper's track listing has Experiments as the last disc... if this is really the last one (and Ian says it's not) then there's no finer way to finish.
Then there's two DVDs. The first is a motley collection of promo films, TV appearances and concert clips from the past 40 years. Disc 2 includes the 1979 Rhyerson Theatre show from Toronto which was broadcast on TV and has circulated amonst fans for years. There's also the Ian Hunter Rocks show from 1981, previously only issued on VHS (and Laserdisc). Then there's the Strings Attached show from Oslo in 2002. This has two tracks not included on the original DVD and a great way to round off a fascination collection. The 'Strings Attached' show is also in real-time sequence (unlike the original).
There is also a lavish hard-cover book which presents a biography of Ian's career so far, together with a track-by-track run-down of all the material in this collection, with Ian's (at times) brutally honest opinion. The book ends with tributes from a whole host of fellow musicians, all of whom are unstinting in their praise. Whorrabloke!
There is also a replica music paper, which contains reproductions of album and gig reviews from the past forty years. Finally, there is an Alien Boy-era lithograph (why don't they call it a photo?), signed by Ian.
The whole is presented in a large presentation case, complete with Escher-inspired artwork.
The whole collection is limited to just 2500 copies and Proper have stated that none of the (extra) discs will be available separately. So if you want any of these extras, you need to buy this box!
The cost is a whopping £250. This collection, therefore, is not aimed at the casual fan but the dedicated Ian Hunter fan (albeit one with very deep pockets). Given that such a fan will already own most if not all of the regular discs, this works out at £250 for the just nine "new" CDs and two DVDs. Whether this is worth the cost is a question for the individual fan to answer.
Ian has said his career isn't yet finished (he turned 77 in 2016!), but if it were to end now this set is an excellent way to bring the curtain down on the career of one of Britain's finest-ever rock stars.
Unsurpassable.
The Moon Upstairs (live 8th October 2012) | 5:21 | Originally a Mott The Hoople track. This live version (recorded at the John Dee, Oslo Norway) was released on Bag Of Tricks (Vol 3) (box set only). |